Professional Associations » Posts & Articles

Is Your Association “Walking the Talk”?

August 9th, 2010. Written by Doreen Ashton Wagner

Destination Marketing Association InternationalRecently I attended the annual convention and business exchange of DMAI, the Destination Marketing Association International.  As a trade association regrouping Convention & Visitor Bureaus (CVBs, a.k.a. Destination Marketing Organizations or DMOs), DMAI is essentially an association of associations.

This was my first attendance at the event, and I learned a lot about what DMOs face such as pressures from their own members, government funding, etc.

But one item struck me as ironic and unfortunate. 

DMAI advocates Corporate Social Responsibility for its members.  The convention program even featured on a session on CSR with Jonathan Greenblatt, co-founder of Ethos Water (which is sold at Starbucks).

An informative session it was, except that message rang false for me because of what was happening in the coffee breaks…  Because of my long-time association with MPI, CSR to me also means the “greening” of meetings.  Imagine my disappointment when I saw the coffee break stations had paper coffee cups and plastic lids, as well as the usual china.  Even more disappointing was that most people were reaching for the disposable stuff before going back to their session.  Why?

Aren’t china cups a greener solution?  And given the choice, why would delegates choose disposables unless they are going to leave the premises (which most DMAI delegates were not)?  Why would the Westin Diplomat, which presumably abides by the Starwood Hotels & Resorts Environmental Sustanibility Policy, even offer the paper cup alternative?  Did I miss something?

I walked away feeling like perhaps DMAI was not walking the talk, and needed to learn more about CSR and the greening of business tourism.   

The experience made me think.  Are we walking the talk?  Are the other associations I belong to walking the talk.  Is your association walking the talk?  Please share your thoughts…

When You’re Stuck with the Boss’ Son…

July 12th, 2010. Written by Doreen Ashton Wagner

Nygel PelletierWe help dozens of organizations every year to update their database.  At times we come across some clients who aren’t able to outsource the cleansing process.  This was the case recently with a law enforcement association who couldn’t export their data for cleansing because their CRM had limitations that required too much of their IT consultant’s very expensive time. 

We would have loved to do the work, but it just wasn’t mean to be.  Our recommendation was for them to hire temporary help.  This project would have taken us just two weeks to complete, and now this is going to take them all summer. 

Fortunately we were able to connect them with a candidate with roots in our area in Glengarry County.  Nygel Pelletier is a former AHL referree (that’s him pictured above!) whose next dream is to get into law enforcement; he was only too eager to get the experience for his résumé!

At times association administrators cannot convince their board or their senior executives that outsourcing is a more efficient way to go.  They are simply told to “hire a student”.   We love students, but what if what if you’re stuck with the boss’ son as your intern to help you clean up your database this summer?  Our client was very happy with how things worked out with Nygel, so we compiled the tips we gave them for your reference: 

  1. Establish a clear goal – What information needs to be updated?  What titles/positions or functions are you trying to get information on and why?  For instance, if you’re trying to update a list of potential exhibitors for your tradeshow, outline those potential titles who may oversee the decision to exhibit at events.  Make sure your intern understands how to explain this purpose to the receptionist.
  2. Write out a script – Have your intern write out exactly what they’ll say.  Play act with them any potential objections so they can present themselves professionally.  (e.g. Receptionist: “I’m sorry; I have no idea who would want to exhibit at your Widget Association Show.” Intern: “I understand.  Perhaps someone in your marketing department would know.  Can you please transfer me?”)
  3. Define phone vs. online approaches – The internet is a great tool, but don’t assume contact names are easily found online.  Sometimes it’s quicker to call up a company and talk to a human being than to search for people online.  Also decide whether the intern will have an email address to send requests for update.
  4. Take the time to train – Supervising a less experienced staff member doing tedious work is often a challenge for busy managers.  Updating a list is not rocket science, but it is an art to convince people to give you the time of day to update any information.  Make sure you take the time to show the person what you want, and how they should sound.  Have them listen to you updating the information so they hear how it’s done.
  5. Keep track of progress – If updating is taking place “live” in your database (and not just on an Excel spreadsheet), make sure you print out a master list, by account/organization name or whatever order makes sense.  Have your intern keep track of their progress by checking off organizations as they are completed.
  6. Spot check – Make sure the information is updated correctly and thoroughly.  It’s stating the obvious, I know, but it’s easy do a great job updating names and forgetting to check that the company is still at the same address.   Spot check records if you can by verifying zip/postal codes, and clicking through to websites to make sure the information is correct.  Have someone else check on a few records, just to make sure things are going smoothly.
  7. Establish metrics – After 3-4 days, your intern should be able to tell you how many records he/she has been able to update per hour.  As we’ve discussed in a previous post, an experienced person should be able to update 10-15 records per hour (we define one record as one contact per company; so 2 contacts at the same location = 2 records).  If the information is particularly dated or obscure, the pace may be closer to 8-12 records per hour.  A pace less than that and your intern may have productivity issues or may be overwhelmed with the task.

And last but not least, make sure your intern realizes how vital their work is!  A clean list is the starting point for any effective and sustainable direct marketing effort.  Don’t let them think you undervalue their work!

Why Belong to an Association?

April 19th, 2010. Written by Doreen Ashton Wagner

In its 2010 Association Trends Survey, the U.S.-based Association Management Company Institute (AMC Institute) reports that its members identified membership development as a top priority, with “more than 85 percent of respondents strategizing ways for their association clients to recruit and retain members this year.”

Membership recruitment and retention have always been a top issue for association managers.  But the recent economic turmoil undoubtedly is causing members to question the value of their association membership and prospective members to delay their decision to join. 

Smart association managers wonder: why do professionals choose to belong to an association?

A 2007 study by the American Society of Association Executives and The Centre for Association Leadership surveyed nearly 17,000 professionals to find out their reasons for joining an association. The Decision to Join: How Individuals Determine Value and Why They Choose to Belong lists the following personal benefits as factors that can influence an individual’s decision to join a professional association:

  • Opportunity to network with other professionals in the field
  • Access to the most up-to-date information in the field
  • Professional development or educational program offerings
  • Opportunity to gain leadership experience
  • Access to career information and employment opportunities
  • Access to products, services and suppliers
  • Reference directory to members/practitioners
  • Member discounts or group purchasing opportunities

 Benefits to the member’s field or profession were also factors that could positively influence a person’s membership decision:

  • Promoting a greater appreciation of the role and value of the field among practitioners
  • Providing standards or guidelines that support quality
  • Maintaining a code of ethics for practice
  • Influencing legislation and regulations that affect the field
  • Promoting greater public awareness of contributions in the field
  • Supporting student education and entry into the field
  • Certifying those who meet critical competency standards
  • Gathering, analyzing, and publishing data on trends in the fields
  • Attracting competent people into the field
  • Conducting research on significant issues affecting the field
  • The association’s role in defining critical competencies
  • Providing awards or recognition for excellence in the field

Have reasons to join an association changed since this study took place in 2007?  Are some of the reasons more important now than before the downturn?  We’d love to hear your thoughts.

Twitter, the Olympics & Association Membership

March 5th, 2010. Written by Doreen Ashton Wagner

Last month I had the fortune of attending  MPI‘s MeetDifferent.  Like many, I had curtailed my travels in the last year, and had not participated in any international association meetings since 2007.  I am very glad I decided to attend this event; the lessons were well worth my investment.

Insight #1

MPI has been working hard over the last few years to integrate social media in its communication to engage its members.  Their site offered blogging features early in the game.  MPI has also fostered communities outside their virtual borders with LinkedIn, where I belong to two MPI Groups, the global one and my Chapter’s.  For MeetDifferent MPI introduced an event social media site called Pathable, and even had a MeetDifferent iPhone app.

Most impressive, and pervasive, was the use of Twitter prior to, during and after the event.  The first workshop I took at the conference was Jim Spellos’ Tweet-Different session, who taught us the five basic things I needed to know to tweet.  Using the hashtag #md10 (for “MeetDifferent10″) dozens of us connected virtually with each other as well as with colleagues who could not be there.

This was my first Ah-ha moment.  I knew social media was altering the landscape, but I had dismissed Twitter as more of a fringe medium.  I realized it has serious business applications and I had some catching up to do.

I wasn’t the only one feeling overwhelmed.  One senior meeting planner from a large Toronto-based consulting firm said, “OMG, with everything else I have to do, when am I going to have the time to tweet too?”  Then she realized she herself didn’t have to become part of the “twitterati.” She needed to understand how the medium works so she could formulate the appropriate communication strategies for her meetings.  Twitter isn’t popular with her firm partners (who tend to be an older audience), but for their recruits and younger managers it was definitely relevant.

Insight #2

On the last day of the conference, the keynote speaker was a dud.  That’s my opinion.  Other people called him a “little flat”  and said his material was OK.  Still, he started his address by reading from his laptop at the podium.  Yes, reading in front of 1100 meeting professionals.

For a few minutes there was an uncomfortable energy in the room.  Then people started tweeting… and leaving. I was one of them.

While I was not in the room to see it, I was told that show host Glenn Thayer was able to work with some of the Twitter feedback and help the meeting “recover”.

The lesson?  Love it or hate it, Twitter is the ultimate audience responder system.  It may help raise the bar for professional speakers, requiring them to be more spontaneous and responsive during the keynote delivery.

Insight #3

My third insight crystallized  after I returned from the event.  I had been so focused on learning about Twitter that I returned home and continued tweeting with my new-found MPI friends about the Olympics.  Watching the Canadian men’s gold hockey game and the Closing Ceremonies while monitoring Twitter was a very different — and rewarding — experience.

As I watched the news reports that night of the giant parties in Vancouver, Toronto and almost everywhere in Canada, I realized:

Younger generations are used to learning online and getting their information from virtual sources.  They don’t feel the need to be present at a seminar or to touch and feel a newspaper the way boomers like me do.  So what compels them to pour into the streets, wave flags and sing the national anthem?  I think it’s making them feel connected to something BIGGER.

My third Ah-ha moment: successful associations will be those who make younger members feel connected to the BIGGER CAUSE, whether at a meeting or between meetings.

It’s still soon after what has now been dubbed “the first Digital Olympics” but I bet that we have just created a new generation of patriotic  Canadians like this country has never seen before.  Now if we could only figure out how to get more people to vote…

Download our Brochure